No 'Magic Bullet': Some pet supplements skimp on ingredients, lab testing reveals

Arthritis supplements bought by millions of pet owners for their dogs, cats and horses sometimes skimp on the ingredients the makers claim can help aching paws and aging joints, and some contain high amounts of lead, an independent laboratory found.

Four of the six joint supplements for animals tested by lacked the amounts of glucosamine or chondroitin promised on their labels or had other flaws, such as lead. Wider testing by a trade group of 87 brands found that one-quarter fell short.

Over-the-counter dietary supplements for humans do not have to be proved safe or effective before they are sold, and pills for pets get even less scrutiny.

"There is, and there always has been," a quality problem, although many companies do a good job, said Mark Blumenthal of the American Botanical Council, which tracks research on herbal products.

Even when these supplements contain what they claim, there is little evidence that they work, veterinary experts say. A large government study of people with arthritis found that glucosamine and chondroitin did no better than dummy pills in easing mild pain.

Testing these supplements on pets is more difficult.

"You can't ask a dog or a cat to give you a subjective impression of how they're feeling after taking the product for several days. They can't say, 'On a scale of 1 to 5, I feel better or worse,' " Blumenthal said.

Giving supplements to an ailing pet can make its owner feel better, though. "The owner shelled out money for the pills and wants to believe they are helping," Blumenthal said.

Prevention rather than treatment

Dr. Steven Baker, veterinarian at Coffee Road Veterinary Clinic in Modesto, said he doesn't recommend supplements.

"I'm not an expert, but my understanding has been that supplements primarily are to provide nutritional supplements to increase the production of joint fluid as a lubricant more to prevent arthritis rather than to treat arthritis that is present," he said.

"Once arthritis is present, we have a whole regimen of pain management medications ... to improve the quality of life and reduce the pain levels.

"I think as a preventative, (supplements) probably do some good. I don't know that they do any damage in any way, but I'm not qualified to say they work all that well. I know a lot of people believe that they do."

He added that he's never seen a pet at his clinic that was suffering from an adverse reaction to the supplements, which are becoming increasingly popular.

Up to one-third of dogs and cats in the United States are given supplements, a government report estimates. Sales of pet supplements have roughly doubled since 2003, to nearly $1 billion a year in the United States, according to the Nutrition Business Journal.

Many pet owners believe they make a difference.

Nicole Albino, who lives in New York City, said her dog Chakka was constantly chewing and licking his knees until her veterinarian recommended glucosamine and chondroitin.

After taking the pills for a year, "he's definitely been licking his knees a lot less," she said. The dog resumed when she ran out of the stuff for a few weeks. "It just seems to help," Albino said.

Few high-quality studies have tested the effectiveness of animal supplements. The Food and Drug Administration says these products are not bound by quality rules for human ones.

In 2007, the FDA asked an expert panel to look into three popular pet supplements — lutein, evening primrose oil and garlic — but the group could not agree on a safe upper limit.

"Many people presume that supplements are safer than drugs, but the reality is that there is very limited safety data on dietary supplements for horses, dogs, and cats," the panel concluded.

Also in 2007, pet food tainted with melamine sickened and killed thousands of cats and dogs. Melamine can mimic protein in some lab tests, and protein costs much more than melamine.

Similarly, certain substances can fool tests for chondroitin, an expensive joint-supplement ingredient, said Dr. Tod Cooperman, president of The company tests supplements for manufacturers that want its seal of approval, and publishes ratings for subscribers.

Chondroitin usually comes from pig and cow cartilage, although shark and chicken cartilage can be used, as well as algae.

Glucosamine usually comes from the shells of crabs. It is also sold in chemical forms, which might surprise people who think of supplements as "natural" products.

Failing to meet standards's most recent tests found that four of six pet supplements failed to meet quality standards, usually because of too little chondroitin. One contained only 17 percent of the promised chondroitin.

The National Animal Supplement Council, a San Diego trade group, found that 28 percent of the 87 brands it tested in April did not contain what was claimed, said council president, William Bookout. The group doesn't name names, but it uses the results to help members improve quality control.

"Sometimes a company doesn't even realize they have a problem, or a company can make an honest mistake," Bookout said.

He warns consumers not to expect too much from a pill: "There isn't any magic bullet out there. It is not hip replacement in a bottle."

Bee staff writer Sue Nowicki contributed to this report.

On the Net: National Academy of Sciences report,