Young recruits draw scrutiny

APPLE VALLEY, Minn. — When Tyus Jones took the floor for his first varsity practice last fall, Tubby Smith was there to watch the budding star — who happens to be an eighth grader.

For kids like Jones, who plays at Apple Valley High School in this Minneapolis suburb, it's not unusual for a college coach to enter the picture well before calculus appears in the curriculum.

Young teens are attracting ever-more attention from coaches in the competitive and lucrative world of major college basketball.

A concerned NCAA is trying to keep control of the situation, having recently clarified a rule to try to better protect middle-school prospects and raising the possibility of future prohibition on the earliest scholarship offers.

With help from family and coaches, Jones is just trying to stay grounded and get better at his game. It's too early, he says, to actually consider where he might want to play next.

"Down the road I'll have to look into it a little more," Jones said.

Sleek and slender, 6 feet tall and 13 years old, Jones helped lead Apple Valley this season to a 20-8 overall record.

"There's so much curiosity about him," head coach Zach Goring said. "We've had the biggest crowds we've ever had. He represents our program so well."

When his days were done at the middle school up the road, Jones would walk over to practice with the Eagles and develop his point-guard skills against guys much bigger and older. With four more years to grow and mature, one can only guess about his potential.

For top prospects like Jones, a coach like Smith must start tracking his development right away or risk falling behind in the race to secure a commitment — and eventually a signed national letter of intent — from a prize recruit in the area.

"It's almost silly what age you can find kids ranked at," said Reggie Minton, vice president of the National Association of Basketball Coaches. "You can find out who is the top fifth grader, sixth grader, seventh grader in the country. It's out there, it's on the Internet, and it's starting to carry some weight."

Coaches aren't allowed to communicate much at all with recruits until midway through high school. In the past, summer camps for young prospects were an indirect way to start the process early, but the NCAA last year amended a men's basketball rule to require seventh- and eighth-graders attending those camps to be covered by the same guidelines for high-schoolers.

The NCAA is continuing to examine the issue of young recruiting.

"I think this is a growing concern, and many believe this is an unfortunate byproduct of today's recruiting culture," NCAA vice president of academic and membership affairs Kevin Lennon said.

The current situation puts both player and coach in a bind, said Jerry Meyer, a recruiting analyst for, which doesn't start ranking prospects until they're sophomores.

"They're enamored by the attention, but then it becomes tiresome and they want to get it over with and commit," Meyer said. Then, coaches are in "an arms race. We'd rather not build nuclear weapons because they destroy the world, but what else can we do when other people are building them?"

So how young is too young? North Carolina coach Roy Williams spoke last week about a couple of his top incoming recruits — Kendall Marshall and Harrison Barnes — telling him previously how he was one of the last coaches to offer them scholarships.

That was two years ago when they were sophomores, which already "scared" Williams.

Smith was asked about the youngest player he ever started recruiting. "My sons," he said, straight-faced. "I started tracking them when they were conceived."