Marion Gardner: Tree expert approves of council’s decision

Re: “Saplings coming to McNamara Park” (Page A1, March 18): Between the lines I heard the words “instant gratification.” I also heard the words “bigger is better.” I differ with those who think bigger is better when it comes to plant material. The writer referred to 24-inch trees. I assume this means the measurement of the box or tub the tree is grown in. I offer the following information as a nurseryman and grower of hardy ornamentals, shade and flowering trees for 50 years, as chairman of the American Nurserymen Associations Grades and Standards Committee for six years, and as a founding member of the ANA National Shade Tree Committee:

The bigger the container the more the chance of the plant being grown in more than one container in its lifetime. Each container contributes to the circling of the roots in the containers. The life-expectancy of the plant is potentially compromised. Large plants are exposed to more shock when transported and transplanted. Younger, more vigorous, trees will often catch-up and outgrow the larger tree, depending on variety and care.

I think the city council made a wise decision, since money does not grow on trees.

This story was originally published March 23, 2015 at 1:30 PM with the headline "Marion Gardner: Tree expert approves of council’s decision."